WH On Collision Course With Bishops Over Abortion
WASHINGTON (AP) - The White House is on a collision course with Catholic bishops in an intractable dispute over abortion that could blow up the fragile political coalition behind President Barack Obama's health care overhaul.
A top Obama administration official on Thursday praised the new Senate health care bill's attempt to find a compromise on abortion coverage - even as an official of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops said Sen. Harry Reid's bill is the worst he's seen so far on the divisive issue.
The bishops were instrumental in getting tough anti-abortion language adopted by the House, forcing Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., to accept restrictions that outraged liberals as the price for passing the Democratic health care bill. Reid, D-Nev., now faces a similar choice: Ultimately, he will need the votes of Democratic senators who oppose abortion to get his bill through the Senate.
So far, Reid has steered the Senate bill in a direction that abortion rights supporters can live with: allowing coverage for abortion in federally subsidized health care plans, provided that beneficiaries' own premiums are used to pay for the procedure. But abortion opponents say his compromise would gut current federal restrictions on abortion funding.
Featured Talent
On FOX News Channel
Follow Fox Nation
FOX Forum Posts
- Demonizing the Insurance Industry Is Not the Answer
- Bomb Iran or Let Them Get the Bomb?
- ABC Is Guilty of Checkbook Journalism
- SEN. LAMAR ALEXANDER: Please, Mr. President, Listen to the People
- The Power of a Deem
- DANA PERINO: The Power of a Puppy
- Obama's Presidency Is On the Line -- And It Shows
- Health Care on Track for a Vote: Will It Pass?
- The CBO's Sleight of Hand On Health Care
- Report from Afghanistan's 'Opium Central'
Most Talked About
- Exclusive: Obama Endorses Slaughter Rule, Louisiana Purchase
- Jon Voight's Call to Arms: Come to D.C. Saturday to Oppose Obamacare
- CBO Score Called a 'Lie'
- Wash. Times Op-ed: Impeach the President?
- Media Outraged Baier Would Dare Interrupt Obama
- Obama Privately Admits Health Care Is His Waterloo
- 'Pacific' Takes Ratings Hit: Did Hanks' 'Racism' Remark Hurt?
- Rep. Rips 'Arrogant, Ignorant, Incompetent' Pelosi
- Dems Vote for Slaughter House Rule
- Moore: Republicans Good at Being Bullies and Being Greedy
Real American Stories
FOX Fan
In a Bunker
Liars, bait and switchers...they'll just come up with something and change it. I don't know when I've been so sad for this great nation. These are the swarmiest people that can be bought and sold, arm twisted and they don't friggin care!! If they did believe in God, they wouldn't be doing any of this stuff. They want us to give up, but the fight has just begun!!!!
Kasperle
I am not Catholic, not Christian and certainly not a troll either.
I DO NOT AGREE with ABORTION unles it is a medical imperative.
This does not mean that soemone can use the idiotic reason that it is mentally to taxing or any other such lame excuse. You get pregnant you go girl and become a mother. Take responsibility! Men who make girls pregnant do the same. Become a father - it will make your life better.
If a woman is raped then she has the right to an abortion.
There may be a couple of other situations that require special dispensation.
Beyond these - ABORTIONS are a disgrace. They are a demeaning of life and ultimately lead to the decay of our self esteem.
To all these liberal wowsers out there that think otherwise. - you will receive what you sow. For many of you lame and unfortunate fools you have already done so. Just look at your empty and pathetic lives. All intelect and no soul. Pathetic to the nth degree, get a grip people!!!
Democrats that vote for this abominatrion of a health care disaster of a bill will be destroyed. Mark my words this is a war for the quality of life of humans and you are on the other side people.
Excalibur
..........When ANY society devalues human life the moral fiber of that nation begins to unravel..........we are seeing that progression here in the US.........our culture is devolving.........we are creating very little that is beautiful and meaningful........technology does not make the soul soar..........!
CHIP
The bishop of San Francisco, needs to have a little "chat", with Pelosi.
In a Bunker
Didn't you mean "exorcism"?
Benana
I think that God or Jesus needs to have a chat with Pelosi. A bishop in S.F. is already pretty weak. She did grow up in Baltimore's "Little Italy" and I'm sure a bishop from there would give her a good talking to.
Benana
I think that God or Jesus needs to have a chat with Pelosi. A bishop in S.F. is already pretty weak. She did grow up in Baltimore's "Little Italy" and I'm sure a bishop from there would give her a good talking to.
WE NEED CIA PROTECTION
ITS NOT JUST ABOUT ABORTION!
JOIN US IN A NEW EFFORT TO STOP THE INSANE ATTACK ON OUR COUNTRY BY OBAMA & THE LIBERAL LEFT!
STOP OBAMA CARE !
STOP THE 9/11 TRIALS!!
CONTACT THE DEMS IN THE SENATE & TELL THEM THAT WE WILL NO LONGER BE IGNORED!
& WE DEMAND A END TO THE ONE PARTY RULE & THE DICTATORSHIP STYLE GOVERMENT THAT IS BEING FORMED BY OBAMA!
A REVOLT IS NEAR! IF OUR GOVERMENT CONTINUES TO IGNORE THE WILL OF THE MAJORITY!
KEEP THE 9/11 trials out of NEW YORK!
FIGHT OBAMA & THE LIBERAL LEFT!
URGENT! Sign The Letter To President Obama
FOLLOW THIS LINK http://stormlobby.50webs.com STOP obama!!!!
support the letter sent by 9/11 Families for a Safe & Strong America and theBravest.com
urging you to not bring the terrorist detainees held at Guantanamo Bay to trial in Article III courts.
CLICK HERE TO EMAIL ATTORNEY GENERAL OFFICE AskDOJ@usdoj.gov.
CONTACT CONGRESS & THE SENATE AT http://stormlobby.50webs.com
LINK TO MY WEBSITE! USE MY LINK IN YOUR POST! SEND PEOPLE TO MY SITE TO LOBBY CONGRESS!
http://stormlobby.50webs.com
Follow me on twitter at http://twitter.com/stormlobby
Jenney
Hope Fr. Jenkings or Jennings was fired from Notre Dame. barack sure fooled him. If you are Catholic, write your Bishop to thank him for finally speaking out. Christians shouldn't contribute financially to babies being harpooned in their heads at 9 months in the womb.
Ameritianity
VISIT: www.ameritianity.com
(1) The Muslim and the Black Preachers
(2) Healthcare and Prosperity
(3) Latest Obama Appointees
(4) Radical/Liberal Rulebook
(5) Narcissistic Power
(6) An American Coup
(7) Obama speaks about Christianity
(8) Obama on his Dislike of the Constitution
(9) Obama speaks about “Whittie”
(10) A solution for HealthCare
(11) Indoctrination of our children to sing the praises of Obama
(12) Blacks say opposition to “ObamaCare” is not about racism
(13) “Jesus loves the little children in the womb”
VISIT: www.ameritianity.com
joeyblueyes
BNISHOPS MARCH ON THE BLACK MUSLIM OBITLA AND CHRISTIANS WILL MARCH WITH YOU, SAVE THE BABIES AND SAVE OUR ONCE GREAT NATION, AND DO NOT SUPPORT, THE HERETICS OF NOTRE DAME
rammey
More power to the bishops. Anything and everything to stop the progressives!!
Don't Drink the Cool Aid
Any catholic senator or congressman voting for a health care bill that contains money for abortion should be excommunicated from the church. Abortion is Murder.
Jim in JAX
Well said, and I certainly agree. It's about time morality mattered to these elected buffoons we have in office.
SABINE
TOOK THE WORDS RIGHT OUT OF MY MOUTH BUT LIKE THE LAW ABOUT TREASON, SADLY WILL NOT BE ENFORCED. WE HAVE BECOME WAY TOO LEANIANT.
Lourdes
How much does an abortion cost anyway? Women who want one should pay for it themselves.
joeyblueyes
HEY PRIESTS CAN YOU PRAY AND MARCH AGAINST THE BLACK MUSLIM AT THE SAME TIME. IF THE ANSWER IS YES THE AMERICAN PEOPLE WILL JOIN YOU. I'M NOT TALKING TO THE HERETICS OF NOTRE DAME
US Male
"Of all the dispositions and habits which lead to political prosperity, religion and morality are indispensable supports.
George Washington
Ameritianity
VISIT: www.ameritianity.com
(1) The Muslim and the Black Preachers
(2) Healthcare and Prosperity
(3) Latest Obama Appointees
(4) Radical/Liberal Rulebook
(5) Narcissistic Power
(6) An American Coup
(7) Obama speaks about Christianity
(8) Obama on his Dislike of the Constitution
(9) Obama speaks about “Whittie”
(10) A solution for HealthCare
(11) Indoctrination of our children to sing the praises of Obama
(12) Blacks say opposition to “ObamaCare” is not about racism
(13) “Jesus loves the little children in the womb”
VISIT: www.ameritianity.com
Josey Whales - Missouri
I am talking to you, yes YOU, look in the mirror and convince yourself that your parents made the right decision not to have an abortion!
stoptheinsanity
they better take a stand before the new one world religion comes into power
liberals are destroying this nation
Troll ,You libs support NAMBLA so the pedophile must be the hero in your story , Heres a better one : Obama , a union thug , a member of NARAL ,and an athiest walk into a bar ...
xanty
Harry Reid also needs Excommunication he goes totaly against his churches polocies.
xanty
They need to excommunicate every Catholic that votes for abortion or to pay for abortions
stoptheinsanity
obama believes in partial birth abortion and infanticide,,,who got him elected?
Recon
Yes, glad Bishops are standing up,
Patrick Kennedy 'RI Catholic Bishop announced 'you're DENIED communion'.
This is what Obama does best his way vs. REALITY or gravitas.
What a joke, this is a huge step towards pure communism which is what Obama has been after since he entered politics.
Obama will be a lame duck in one year,
have two years of using his knee pads to get a nickle.
Worry not fellow conservatives, this is the straw that will break their backs. Tea anyone?
stoptheinsanity
with majority of Americans as believers I do NOT know how obama and the dems got elected to pres and majority,,,the biggest issues for them are abortion and gay rights,,,,the fight for abortion paid by US in health care bill will be passed as did the mexico city policy obama reversed, it is time true Christians stand up and be heard and counted.
John63
I would really hope that the Catholic Church would ex-communicate all members of congress that vote for this health care bill, as it is written with abortion in it.
spinfree
I never understood the democratic position on abortion. Above all, the unborn are human beings, but more then that they could grow up to be a liberal. Go figure?
ESP
Kennedy, Kerry, Pelosi, Biden like catholics want it both ways. Communion and abortion. They want to protect the rights of terrorists when the CIA does torture and gets vidal info, but they do not want the rights of the unborn protected.
Throw them out of office. they have no principals
winodrifter
As per Catholic radio, the Bishop of MA denied Teddy burial services in the cathedral in Boston. This is why it was held in the smaller grotto.
Old Guy 5
Now it's time for other religions to join with the catholics and the few evangalicals that also signed. Come on all you television preachers like Hagee, Robertson, etc. get your names on the list and preach it in your churches. Stand up for what is right.
SW
They do they are they have been!
Old Guy 5
I agree with the poster that congratulated the bishop for not giving Kennedy communion. More bishops and piests should stand up for what the catholic chhurch believes and not give sacremental rites to anyone who says their catholic and does not show it by their deeds and speech. This especially should include people in the spotlight that can be models for our chilfren. As far as electing the kind of president we have now - SHAME ON US.
SW
This is true ,and the BIBLE says to :"Examine Yourself before,for he that eateth or drinketh unworthily , eateth and
drinketh damnation to himself."
I would say this is a precise and clear warning.
Midwest Patriot
Give the Catholic Bishops a pat on the back for speaking out. Although overdue, it's a good step.
fed up with them all
It's way past time they stood up and said it stinks. God bless each and everyone of them.
Mrs McC
I'm so sick of all the Kennedy's acting like they are some sort of pseudo-royalty. They act like laws and morality do not apply to them, just to the "little people." I hope the Bishops show some backbone and unite against this little loser.
Paladin
The president with the muslim name has stated that "we do not consider ourselves a Christian nation". Speak for yourself BHO. Hooray for the Catholic Bishops.
Winston Cupp
Bravo to the church. Bravo for the Bishop in RI denying communion to Kennedy. And shame on the church for allowing communion for Nancy Pelosi, Kennedy in the other states, and John Kerry. And any other Catholic that are pro-abortion.
US Male
"Always stand on principle, even if you have to stand alone."
John Quincy Adams
US Male
"If we ever forget that we are one nation under God, then we will be one nation gone under."
Ronald Reagan
biker
I posted this quote in the teachers lounge in the school I work at..and believe it or not..it is still there after a year. There is still hope.
US Male
Your a Great American!!!
US Male
"Men will ultimately be governed by God or by tyrants."
Benjamin Franklin
isikmoon
SANTA RUSH
Oh, jingle bells jingle bells
Jingle all the time
Santa Rush will give us our Freedom
We behaved very well all this year
We don't deserve a Christmas fear
Santa please let us see and hear
That you would fight Obamacare
Oh, jingle bells jingle bells
Jingle all the time
Santa Rush will give us our Freedom
Santa Rush is now needed
By the children, sick and elderly
And by women waiting to be tested
For breast cancer until they're fifty
Oh, jingle bells jingle bells
Jingle all the time
Santa Rush will save us from Obama doom
Santa bring us Freemarket Care
Accessible to everyone everywhere
Travel and change of place I dare
Please rescue us from prisonal care.
www.rushforpresident.com
therepublicrevealed
Does the WH believe in G/d???????????????
http://www.therepublicrevealed.com/forums/index.php?topic=296.0
Excalibur
.........the WH believes in GOLD................!
biker
I do not believe in abortion...If you choose to have an abortion, that is your right..however don't expect me to pay for it. The pro abortion organizations can start a fund for the government to use to pay for these abortions. Not American citizens tax dollars.
WE NEED CIA PROTECTION
THE VOTE PASSED THAT WILL ALLOW THE DEBATE ON GOVE RUN OBAMACARE TO GO FORWARD!
DEBATE WILL BEGIN IN ABOUT A WEEK! & YOU WAIT & SEE A FINAL VOTE WILL BE TAKEN
JUST BEFORE CHRISTMAS! (WHEN THEY KNOW EVERYONE IS WANTING TO GO HOME)
THIS YES VOTE WAS PAID FOR WITH YOUR TAX DOLLERS!
URGENT! Sign The Letter To President Obama
FOLLOW THIS LINK http://stormlobby.50webs.com STOP obama!!!!
support the letter sent by 9/11 Families for a Safe & Strong America and theBravest.com
urging you to not bring the terrorist detainees held at Guantanamo Bay to trial in Article III courts.
CLICK HERE TO EMAIL ATTORNEY GENERAL OFFICE AskDOJ@usdoj.gov.
LINK TO MY WEBSITE! USE MY LINK IN YOUR POST! SEND PEOPLE TO MY SITE TO LOBBY CONGRESS!
http://stormlobby.50webs.com
SUPPORT THE EMAIL REVOLUTION AGAINST THE LIBS IN CONGRESS & PRESIDENT OBAMA!
CONTACT CONGRESS,OBAMA, OR THE LIBERAL MEDIA CNN,MSNBC,CBS,ABC,NBC
CONTACT THEM AT http://stormlobby.50webs.com ACT NOW!
ISSUES!
HEALTHCARE! Once it passes their is no going back! (THINK)
CAP & TRADE! You will pay more for everything you buy! (THINK)
OBAMAS CZARS! Nobody including congress knows what they are doing! (THINK)
IMMIGRATION REFORM! Obama plans to make all illegals (THINK)
OBAMA IN OUR SCHOOLS (SICK)
NOTHING obama is doing is good for our country! Hes destroying it!
If we don't act & act now tomarrow may be to late!
Post my link on myspace ,twitter,youtube,facebook http://stormlobby.50webs.com
CONTACT CONGRESS AT http://stormlobby.50webs.com
Follow me on twitter at http://twitter.com/stormlobby!!!
support the letter sent by 9/11 Families for a Safe & Strong America and theBravest.com
urging you to not bring the terrorist detainees held at Guantanamo Bay to trial in Article III courts.
LINK TO MY WEBSITE! USE MY LINK IN YOUR POST! SEND PEOPLE TO MY SITE TO LOBBY CONGRESS!
http://stormlobby.50webs.com